Turn your mortgage into a wealth-building tool. Smith Manoeuvre strategies, tax-smart planning, and honest math from two Canadian mortgage strategists.
Great-West Lifeco's $1B Q2: Why Canada Saw Outflows and Sales Growth at Once
Great-West Lifeco closed the second quarter of 2024 with $1.03 billion in net earnings and a capital ratio of 133%, nearly a third higher than the regulatory floor. The numbers looked strong. But underneath, the Canadian segment was doing two contradictory things at the same time: winning new business and losing existing money.
Insurance and annuity sales in Canada climbed sharply year-over-year, driven by group benefits and wealth products. At the same time, net asset outflows accelerated. More people bought in. More assets walked out. The pattern doesn't make intuitive sense until you separate what kind of money is flowing where.
The institutional side held, the retail side bled
Group insurance, the policies employers buy to cover their workers, remained steady. Sales of annuities and segregated funds also grew, particularly among retirees converting RRSP balances into guaranteed income streams. These are institutionally adjacent products: structured, deliberate purchases made with advice or employer sponsorship.
What left were retail mutual fund assets. Canadian households pulled billions out of equity-heavy mutual funds in 2023 and 2024, redirecting the money into GICs and high-interest savings accounts offered by the same banks. The five-year GIC rate in early 2024 hovered near 5.5%, the highest level since 2007. A balanced mutual fund charging 2% in fees and delivering 6% gross suddenly looked unappealing next to a guaranteed 5.5% with no volatility and no management expense ratio.
Great-West's proprietary wealth platforms, particularly those serving the mass-affluent retail segment, felt that preference shift directly. Advisors were still bringing in new clients and writing new group plans, but the existing book of retail fund assets was shrinking faster than new sales could replace it. Sales growth and asset outflows are not opposites when they happen in different product lines.
U.S. retirement masked Canadian headwinds
Base earnings, the measure that strips out market noise and one-time items, hit $1.26 billion for the quarter, roughly $230 million higher than reported net earnings. The gap reflects the accounting impact of IFRS 17, which Great-West adopted in 2023 and which tends to smooth profit recognition over time rather than booking it upfront.
The larger structural point is that Empower, the U.S. retirement subsidiary, continued to post record fee income. Empower absorbed Prudential's full-service retirement business in 2022 and now manages over $1.4 trillion in participant assets. Fee-based revenue from recordkeeping, advice, and plan administration grew faster than any product line in Canada. The U.S. became the earnings anchor.
That shift matters because it changes what the company is optimizing for. A decade ago, Great-West's Canadian operations were the core and the U.S. was the hedge. By mid-2024, the U.S. drove more of the growth and absorbed more of the management focus. Canadian retail wealth became something to defend rather than expand.
Rate reversal will test the model
Higher interest rates lifted reinvestment yields on the general fund, mostly bonds and commercial mortgages backing policyholder liabilities. That tailwind added roughly 60 basis points to the effective yield on new money invested in 2024 compared to 2022. As the Bank of Canada cuts rates through 2025 and into 2026, that margin compresses.
The question is whether the asset outflows slow when GICs roll over at lower rates. If five-year GICs reset closer to 3%, the yield advantage over diversified funds narrows. But by then, some of the exited assets will have been reallocated into direct brokerage accounts or robo-advisors that Great-West doesn't capture. Winning the money back is harder than keeping it.
Great-West's Q2 showed a company in mid-transition: institutionally sound, retail-challenged, and increasingly reliant on U.S. fee income to offset domestic margin pressure. The paradox of rising sales and falling assets isn't a contradiction. It's a segmentation problem dressed up as a headline number.
Great-West Lifeco closed the second quarter of 2024 with $1.03 billion in net earnings and a capital ratio of 133%, nearly a third higher than the regulatory floor. The numbers looked strong. But underneath, the Canadian segment was doing two contradictory things at the same time: winning new business and losing existing money.
Insurance and annuity sales in Canada climbed sharply year-over-year, driven by group benefits and wealth products. At the same time, net asset outflows accelerated. More people bought in. More assets walked out. The pattern doesn't make intuitive sense until you separate what kind of money is flowing where.
The institutional side held, the retail side bled
Group insurance, the policies employers buy to cover their workers, remained steady. Sales of annuities and segregated funds also grew, particularly among retirees converting RRSP balances into guaranteed income streams. These are institutionally adjacent products: structured, deliberate purchases made with advice or employer sponsorship.
What left were retail mutual fund assets. Canadian households pulled billions out of equity-heavy mutual funds in 2023 and 2024, redirecting the money into GICs and high-interest savings accounts offered by the same banks. The five-year GIC rate in early 2024 hovered near 5.5%, the highest level since 2007. A balanced mutual fund charging 2% in fees and delivering 6% gross suddenly looked unappealing next to a guaranteed 5.5% with no volatility and no management expense ratio.
Great-West's proprietary wealth platforms, particularly those serving the mass-affluent retail segment, felt that preference shift directly. Advisors were still bringing in new clients and writing new group plans, but the existing book of retail fund assets was shrinking faster than new sales could replace it. Sales growth and asset outflows are not opposites when they happen in different product lines.
U.S. retirement masked Canadian headwinds
Base earnings, the measure that strips out market noise and one-time items, hit $1.26 billion for the quarter, roughly $230 million higher than reported net earnings. The gap reflects the accounting impact of IFRS 17, which Great-West adopted in 2023 and which tends to smooth profit recognition over time rather than booking it upfront.
The larger structural point is that Empower, the U.S. retirement subsidiary, continued to post record fee income. Empower absorbed Prudential's full-service retirement business in 2022 and now manages over $1.4 trillion in participant assets. Fee-based revenue from recordkeeping, advice, and plan administration grew faster than any product line in Canada. The U.S. became the earnings anchor.
That shift matters because it changes what the company is optimizing for. A decade ago, Great-West's Canadian operations were the core and the U.S. was the hedge. By mid-2024, the U.S. drove more of the growth and absorbed more of the management focus. Canadian retail wealth became something to defend rather than expand.
Rate reversal will test the model
Higher interest rates lifted reinvestment yields on the general fund, mostly bonds and commercial mortgages backing policyholder liabilities. That tailwind added roughly 60 basis points to the effective yield on new money invested in 2024 compared to 2022. As the Bank of Canada cuts rates through 2025 and into 2026, that margin compresses.
The question is whether the asset outflows slow when GICs roll over at lower rates. If five-year GICs reset closer to 3%, the yield advantage over diversified funds narrows. But by then, some of the exited assets will have been reallocated into direct brokerage accounts or robo-advisors that Great-West doesn't capture. Winning the money back is harder than keeping it.
Great-West's Q2 showed a company in mid-transition: institutionally sound, retail-challenged, and increasingly reliant on U.S. fee income to offset domestic margin pressure. The paradox of rising sales and falling assets isn't a contradiction. It's a segmentation problem dressed up as a headline number.
Read Next
Realtors Are Walking Away, And the Prenup Surge Tells You Why
Realtors Are Leaving the Industry, and the Numbers Tell You Why
Kelowna Now Ranks First in Canada for Wildfire Risk: What Condo Buyers Need to Verify Before Closing
Kelowna Ranks First for Wildfire Risk in Canada: What Condo Buyers Need to Understand Before Closing